With third quarter GDP being reported next Wednesday – less than a week before election day – the US is still not in recession.
Yes, monetary policy has been tight, but the lags between tighter money and the economy are long and variable. In addition, massive budget deficits continue to provide incomes for a wide range of occupations. The official figures for Fiscal Year 2024 arrived Friday afternoon (isn’t it just like the government to announce bad news right before the weekend!) and the deficit was $1.832 trillion, or what we estimate to be 6.4% of GDP. That’s the second straight year with a deficit in excess of 6.0% of GDP, in spite of an unemployment rate averaging less than 4.0%. These deficits, which are unprecedented in size given peacetime and low unemployment, may have temporarily masked the effects of tighter money.
Meanwhile, innovators and entrepreneurs in high-tech industries and elsewhere have been overcoming government obstacles to push the economy forward. It’s hard to tell how much each factor (government spending or innovation) deserves credit for recent GDP growth, but roughly half of job creation in the past year has been in government and healthcare.
In the meantime, we estimate that Real GDP expanded at a 3.0% annual rate in the third quarter, mostly accounted for by growth in consumer spending. (This estimate is not yet set in stone; reports on Friday about durable goods and next Tuesday about international trade and inventories might lead to an adjustment.)
Consumption: In spite of tepid auto sales, overall consumer spending continues to rise, possibly because of continued government deficits. We estimate that real consumer spending on goods and services, combined, increased at a 3.5% rate, adding 2.4 points to the real GDP growth rate (3.5 times the consumption share of GDP, which is 68%, equals 2.4).
