ECB: It Will Get Harder From Here

The European Central Bank (ECB) cut its deposit facility rate by 25 basis points from 2.75% to 2.5% without opposition among its Governing Council members, and only one abstention from the vote.

Its new staff projections show lower growth expectations and a broadly unchanged inflation outlook. Weak growth and inflation projected at target argue for a policy rate close to neutral, despite still elevated domestic inflation.

Accordingly, the ECB no longer aims for overly restrictive policy but intends to deliver an “appropriate” policy stance. Discussion about the eventual landing zone has gained traction. At the Davos World Economic Forum in January, ECB President Christine Lagarde cited a 1.75–2.25% neutral policy range, based on ECB staff research. However, disagreements have since emerged, and elevated uncertainty is complicating the analysis. It is the data flow that will eventually be the deciding factor in the decision to cut or pause rates at upcoming meetings, and decisions are likely to be more contentious.

Executive Board (EB) member Isabel Schnabel downplayed the relevance of the neutral range estimates, made the case for a higher neutral rate, and questioned whether monetary policy is still restrictive. She also believes a pause in the rate-cutting cycle should be discussed soon. In contrast, EB member Piero Cipollone not only thinks that the current policy setting is overly restrictive, but also urged the ECB to ensure that rate decisions adequately compensate for the tightening induced by the reduction of the balance sheet.

For now, we think policy rates are likely to continue their descent in a cautious fashion, and believe the ECB is not done yet with cutting rates. Market pricing for a terminal rate of around 2% seems reasonable, and remains broadly consistent with our estimates for a neutral policy rate for the euro area. We see downside risks to already weak euro area growth in the near term, mainly on the back of uncertainty around trade; while fiscal measures related to defense and infrastructure should support growth in the medium- to longer-term.

Investment implications

Our highest conviction view is for a steeper interest rate curve. We continue to expect the back end of the interest rate curve to underperform shorter- to medium-term maturities due to rate cuts and rebuilding term premia. With the ECB’s balance sheet shrinking and additional fiscal stimulus, investors are likely to demand higher compensation for investing in longer maturities.