The latest bear-market rally in US stocks has brought investors off the sidelines and provided a welcome reprieve from three quarters of gloom. But traders now need to ask themselves whether the risks continue to justify the potential returns.
The S&P 500 Index has rallied 7.9% since Oct. 12, helped by hardy corporate earnings, stabilizing US Treasury yields and a sense that the sell-off had gone too far. The rally was widely predicted, most prominently by Morgan Stanley strategist Mike Wilson, who characterized it at the time as a “tactical” call, not a sign of a fundamental turning point in the outlook for equities.
Of course, the market is passing through a transition period. Stock valuations have undergone a long period of adjustment to higher interest rates this year, but prices still don’t reflect the sorts of earnings declines expected in a typical recession. That’s in part because the hard economic data and corporate earnings haven’t yet confirmed the bearish forecasts of a growing number of economists. The bear market is experiencing something of an interlude, which has opened the door for short-term speculation.
At the same time, there’s a hard cap on how high stocks can go as long as the Federal Reserve is on the warpath. Monetary policymakers have expressed broad commitment to bringing down the highest inflation in 40 years, and that means higher interest rates and generally tighter financial conditions. If bond yields fall and stock prices rise, the Fed will simply ratchet up its hawkish rhetoric to bring them back in line.
Traders now have to ask themselves whether they’re truly nimble enough to chase this latest short-term rally to culmination without toppling off the inevitable cliff at the end of it. Morgan Stanley’s Wilson has said that the rally could run to 4,000-4,150 (another 3.7% to 7.5% from the current level of 3,859.11) That makes some sense: A couple of key technical indicators suggest that 4,000 is an important level. At this rate, maybe the index even hits 4,000 this week. But after that, the risk-reward calculation could deteriorate swiftly. Consider the multitude of perils ahead:
- The Fed meets Nov. 1-2 and will probably raise the fed funds rate by another 75 basis points. The market is fully braced for the three-quarter percentage point move this month but will be on tenterhooks over hints as to where the rate is going in the months ahead.
- On Nov. 4, the Bureau of Labor Statistics will release the latest payrolls data, which could show a still-strong labor market and fast-growing wages, perhaps encouraging the Fed to push interest rates even higher.
- On Nov. 8, the US will hold midterm elections with control of the Senate and House at stake. The potential for election week violence in a politically polarized country is negative for everyone, as is the prospect of political gridlock with Republicans potentially seizing control of Congress.
Any one of these risk events could certainly swing positive or negative, but the closer the market drifts to the Fed’s implicit ceiling, the worse the risk-reward equation looks heading into that roller coaster six-day period. Stock traders have had some well-deserved fun in the past couple weeks, but they might have to think about getting serious again before the start of November.
Bloomberg News provided this article. For more articles like this please visit
bloomberg.com.
Read more articles by Jonathan Levin
