Eight years ago this week, President Barack Obama gave investors a surprisingly hot trading tip. In office less than two months, he commented that we were at “the point where buying stocks is a potentially good deal if you’ve got a long-term perspective.”
Obama couldn’t have known then how accurate his call was. The market found a bottom that very week, and investors who took the president’s advice managed to get in on the absolute ground floor.
At the time, investor sentiment was at or near record lows. The number of S&P 500 Index stocks trading below $10 a share had grown tenfold since the end of 2007. The New York Stock Exchange, in fact, had to temporarily suspend its requirement that equities trade at more than $1 a share. Giant companies such as Citigroup and General Motors—a share of which cost little more than a pocketful of spare change—were at risk of being delisted.
Today, many of those bullish investors have seen some spectacular gains. Since its low of 666 in March 2009, the S&P 500 has climbed a whopping 260 percent, with not a single year of losses. The average annual return has been over 15.7 percent, based on Bloomberg data. With dividends reinvested, it’s closer to 18 percent.
Just take a look at Apple, which has surged more than 1,080 percent as it introduced or expanded its line of got-to-have, now-ubiquitous products, from the iPhone to iPad.
click to enlarge
To show you just how far we’ve come, I put together a few comparisons of several indices and economic factors between March 2009 and now.
You’ve Come a Long Way, Baby: U.S. Economy Then and Now
|
March 2009 |
Most Recent Data, March 2017 |
Percent Change |
S&P 500 Index |
666.79 (intraday low, March 6) |
2,400.98 (intraday high, March 1) |
260% |
Dow Jones Industrial Average |
6,440.08 (intraday low, March 9) |
21,169.11 (intraday high, March 1) |
228% |
University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index |
69.5 |
96.3 |
38% |
U.S. ISM Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) |
35.8 |
57.7 (February) |
61% |
Housing Starts |
505,000 |
1,290,000 |
155% |
Light Vehicle Sales |
9,552,000 |
17,465,000 |
83% |
Unemployment |
8.7% |
4.7% (February) |
-45% |
Gold |
$885 (intraday low, March 18) |
$1,248.30 (intraday high, March 1) |
41% |
Sources: S&P Dow Jones Indices, Bureau of Economic Analysis, University of Michigan, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Census Bureau, ISM, IBA |
Of course, there have been market skeptics. As others have pointed out, this particular bull run—the second-longest in U.S. history—has arguably been the least loved, with many investors calling it artificial and arguing that it’s been driven not by fundamentals but the Federal Reserve’s policy of record-low interest rates.
click to enlarge
Now there are those who wonder how much longer this bull run can last. And if it ends, will it be with a bang or a whimper?
“Trump Rally” Could Have Further Room to Grow
It’s important to keep in mind the old investing adage, “Bull markets don’t die of old age.” Bear markets have been incited by everything from geopolitical conflicts to stagflation to oil price shocks to financial crises. Although no one can say with all certainty that age is irrelevant in a market’s longevity, there are signs that the current eight-year-old run has further room to grow, at least in the short term.
President Donald Trump’s pro-growth policy proposals, including lower corporate taxes, deregulation and infrastructure spending, have jolted many people’s “animal spirits,” with several indices already hitting near-record highs. In January, the Index of Small Business Optimism posted a reading unseen since 2004, as I shared with you earlier. More recently, the Bloomberg Consumer Comfort Index, which measures American consumers’ views on the U.S. economy and their personal finances, climbed to 50.6, the first time it’s exceeded 50 in a decade. Note how few times it’s risen above that level in the past 17 years.
click to enlarge
And of course there’s the booming jobs market. Following the record 75 straight months of jobs creation under Obama, employers continue to ramp up their rate of hiring even more, indicating a rosy financial and economic outlook. Despite candidate Trump’s tendency to question the validity of encouraging jobs reports before the election, President Trump now has much to brag about in his first full month in office.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), the U.S. added a phenomenal 235,000 jobs in February, with gains made in construction, manufacturing, mining, educational services and health care. The report indicated that mining added 8,000 positions during the month, 20,000 in total since a recent low in October, just before the election. This shows executives’ confidence in Trump, who pledged to revive the industry by eliminating job-killing regulations.
Another recent report was even more generous than the BLS. The ADP National Employment Report showed U.S. employment increasing by nearly 300,000 from January to February. Medium-size businesses—those with between 50 and 499 employees—expanded the most, adding 122,000 positions.
click to enlarge
Gold historically has fallen on better-than-expected jobs reports, but I was happy to see that it actually gained today after eight days of losses. The yellow metal held above $1,200 an ounce, even as it becomes more and more certain that interest rates will be hiked next week.
Valuations High, but Good Deals Can Still Be Found
Some investors right now might be discouraged by high stock valuations. Although it’s true certain sectors are beginning to look expensive—information technology is currently trading at more than 23 times earnings, real estate at 43 times earnings and energy at a whopping 113 times earnings—there are still some attractive deals.
Among them is the airlines industry, which as of today has a very reasonable price-to-earnings ratio of 9.97. At 21.85, the S&P 500 is more than twice as expensive.
This is one of the many reasons why billionaire investor Warren Buffett is bullish on airlines, which he once called a “death trap” for investors. Not only did his holding company Berkshire Hathaway purchase shares of the four big domestic carriers—American, United, Delta and Southwest—but it dramatically expanded those holdings in the fourth quarter, according to regulatory filings. Now there’s even speculation that Buffett and Berkshire Hathaway could be planning to acquire one of these four carriers outright, with Morgan Stanley’s Rajeev Lalwani writing that Southwest’s “domestic focus, robust and sustainable free cash flow, range of growth opportunities, defensible cost structure and more tenured management team” make it a logical candidate.
The Economy and Bond Market
Strengths
- Employers added 235,000 workers to their payrolls in February, the government reported on Friday, a hefty gain that clears the path for the Federal Reserve to raise its benchmark interest rate when it meets next week. World Interest Rate Probability data provided by Bloomberg shows a 100 percent chance the Federal Reserve will raise its key interest rate by 25 basis points to a range of 0.75 percent to 1.00 percent at the conclusion of its March 14-15 meeting.
click to enlarge
- Gallup's measure of U.S. economic confidence jumped to a record high. The U.S. Economic Confidence Index increased by seven points to +16 from February 27 to March 5, marking the highest weekly average in the index's nine-year trend.
- An indicator of the health of the global economy grew at its fastest pace in six years. Data released by the International Air Transport Association showed that revenue passenger kilometers grew by 9.6 percent compared with a year earlier, making for the fastest growth since April 2011.
Weaknesses
- The U.S. trade deficit jumped in January to a five-year high. The Commerce Department said the trade deficit in January rose 9.6 percent to $48.5 billion. This underscored the challenges facing President Donald Trump in fulfilling a campaign pledge to reduce deficits.
- According to the Conference Board’s latest Economic Forecast for the U.S. economy, U.S. economic growth was downgraded in the first quarter from 2.2 percent (annualized) to only 1.6 percent. The data suggests weaker than expected consumer and government construction spending along with a drop in exports of capital goods, resulting in a surge in the trade deficit.
- Initial jobless claims rose by 20,000 to 243,000 last week, more than expected.
Opportunities
- U.S. retail sales for February are released on Wednesday and economists will be on the lookout for strength in consumption.
- The U.S. reports industrial production data on Friday, which is likely to follow suit from this week’s strong factory orders report.
- The Leading Index for February will be released next Friday and investors are optimistic about a strong print given the recent positive economic surprises.
Threats
- Societe Generale strategist Albert Edwards says higher interest rates will trigger a 1994-style "bloodbath" in the bond market. Edwards recalled that before 1994 markets were expecting interest rates to increase, much as they are today. After the Fed initially raised rates, the two-year note yield, which moves inversely to its price, jumped by about 50 basis points.
- President Donald Trump told conservative groups that if the GOP leadership's American Health Care Act did not pass, he would allow Obamacare to collapse and blame its failure on Democrats. Conservative groups contend that the AHCA's tax credits that allow people to purchase insurance are a "Republican entitlement" and the whole bill is simply "Obamacare Lite" or "Obamacare 2.0."
- Peter Navarro, the head of the Trump administration National Trade Council, wrote an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal. Business Insider reports that Navarro laid out why he thinks the U.S. is losing its grip on the economy. He shared his views on GDP growth, trade deficits, and how the U.S. national security depend on keeping American assets in American hands. However, Business Insider states that Navarro doesn’t seem to understand how our economy works.
Gold Market
This week spot gold closed at $1,204.55, down $30.00 per ounce, or 2.43 percent. Gold stocks, as measured by the NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index, ended the week lower though by 2.50 percent. Junior-tiered stocks outperformed seniors for the week, as the S&P/TSX Venture Index slipped just 2.35 percent. The U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar Index finished the week down by 0.16 percent.
Date |
Event |
Survey |
Actual |
Prior |
Mar-6 |
U.S. Durable Goods Orders
|
1.0% |
2.0% |
1.8% |
Mar-8 |
U.S. ADP Employment Change
|
187k |
298k |
261k |
Mar-9 |
ECB Main Refinancing Rate
|
0.000% |
0.000% |
0.000% |
Mar-9 |
U.S. Initial Jobless Claims
|
238k |
243k |
223k |
Mar-10 |
U.S. Change in Nonfarm Payrolls
|
200k |
235k |
238k |
Mar-14 |
Germany CPI YoY
|
2.2% |
-- |
2.2% |
Mar-14 |
Germany ZEW Survey Current Situation
|
77.3 |
-- |
76.4 |
Mar-14 |
Germany ZEW Survey Expectations
|
13.0 |
-- |
10.4 |
Mar-14 |
U.S. PPI Final Demand YoY
|
1.9% |
-- |
1.6% |
Mar-15 |
U.S. CPI YoY
|
2.7% |
-- |
2.5% |
Mar-15 |
FOMC Rate Decision
|
1.00% |
-- |
0.75% |
Mar-16 |
Eurozone CPI Core YoY
|
0.9% |
-- |
0.9% |
Mar-16 |
U.S. Housing Starts
|
1262k |
-- |
1246k |
Mar-16 |
U.S. Initial Jobless Claims
|
245k |
-- |
243k |
Strengths
- The best performing precious metal for the week was gold, down 2.43 percent, but still leading its precious metals peers. Gold imports by India are said to have risen nearly three-fold in February from a year earlier, reports Bloomberg, jumping 175 percent. Jewelers are restocking for the upcoming festival and wedding period that starts next month.
- The U.S. saw its largest trade deficit since March of 2012, reports Bloomberg, as a jump in merchandise imports in January exceeded a smaller gain in shipments overseas. “The wider deficit indicates trade, which subtracted 1.7 percent from fourth-quarter growth, will weigh on the economy in early 2017,” the article continues. A stronger dollar has made exports less competitive and could be hindrance to boosting manufacturing jobs in the U.S. as President Trump promised.
- Joni Teves, strategist at UBS, writes that the research group expects underlying positive sentiment toward gold to remain broadly intact as uncertainty lingers. In its Global Precious Metals Comment, Teves outlines that despite the recent increase in positioning, gold market length remains relatively subdued with net positions in Comex accounting for about 50 percent of the record. Similarly, UBS writes “there really isn’t much expectation of an aggressive selloff in gold – this has been a common theme among our conversations with market participants in different regions.”
Weaknesses
- The worst performing precious metal for the week was platinum, down 5.72 percent. Silver was not far behind with a loss of 5.22 percent.
- According to a weekly Bloomberg survey, nearly half of gold traders and analysts are bearish on gold as the dollar strengthens amid expectations of a Fed rate hike next week. Overseas, the People’s Bank of China reports gold holdings unchanged for a fourth-straight month, coming in at 59.24 million ounces by the end of February. Similarly, Bullionvault’s Gold Investor Index, which measures the balance of client buyers against sellers, fell to the lowest level since July.
- Gold fell below $1,200 an ounce this week, the longest losing streak since October, on better-than-expected U.S. private jobs data – adding to positive economic talk that boosted the dollar. “Three weeks ago the possibility of a rate hike in March was very small, but now it’s 100 percent,” said Bob Takai, CEO and president of Sumitomo Corp. So where exactly does the Fed see rates headed? The chart below gives a quick comparison between the Fed Funds Target versus where the Taylor Rule Estimate, estimating close to 4 percent. The sudden shift to raise rates in March may reflect that the Fed is behind the curve again.
click to enlarge
Threats
- China is facing a shortage in its labor market over the coming decades. Due to China’s long-held one-child policy, the working-age population has been shrinking. About one in three Chinese will be older than 60 by 2050, compared with about one in seven now. Although China reversed the one-child policy in 2015, the government is now considering financial incentives to boost the birth rate.
- Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte may be guilty of crimes against humanity, according to the group Human Rights Watch and others. Under Duterte’s antidrug campaign, thousands of people have been killed, and police have allegedly ordered the extrajudicial killings of drug dealers and users. Although the Philippines is a member of the International Criminal Court, it is unlikely that Duterte would face domestic prosecution while president.
- Tensions between South Korea and China over a U.S. missile defense system are impacting air travel and tourism in the area. Some South Korean and Chinese airline carriers have temporarily suspended certain flights. Goldman Sachs estimates that the economic impact of fewer mainland Chinese taking trips to South Korea will come in at $5 billion.
Emerging Europe
Strengths
- Turkey was the best relative performing country this week, losing 12 basis points. In Moscow, President Erdogan signed a deal to create a Russia-Turkey Investment fund worth $1 billion that could strengthen bilateral economic ties and increase investment flows between both countries.
- The euro was the best performing currency this week, gaining 61 basis points against the U.S. dollar. Hawkish comments out of the European Central Bank (ECB) supported the eurozone bloc currency.
- The consumer discretionary sector was the best performing sector among eastern European markets this week.
Weaknesses
- Russia was the worst performing country this week, losing 4 percent. The Moscow stock exchange is highly correlated with the price of Brent crude oil, which fell to $51.33 per barrel from $55.90 in the past five days, or 8.4 percent. U.S. crude oil inventories surged to another record high.
- The Russian ruble was the worst performing currency this week, losing 1.3 percent against the U.S. dollar. The currency slumped in response to oil’s plunge. According to Bloomberg, the ruble’s 30-day correlation to oil rose to 0.5 from as low as 0.13 on February 20.
- The material sector was the worst performing sector among eastern European markets this week.
Opportunities
- The ECB left its policy unchanged and Mario Draghi said further stimulus measures are less likely as the threats to recovery have become less severe. Inflation spiked in last months and ECB’s economist raised their growth forecast for this year to 1.8 percent from 1.7 percent. The central bank is due to lower its monthly bond purchase program in April to 60 billion euros from 80 billion. The program is set to run until the end of the year.
- Czech Republic’s inflation accelerated to 2.5 percent in February from 2.2 percent in December, the fastest pace since November 2012. The spike in inflation puts pressure on the central bank to exit its three-year koruna appreciation cap.
- European Union leaders re-elected Donald Tusk as the European Council president despite Poland voting against his next two-and-a-half year term. The European Council brings together the government of the 28 EU member states and jointly they set the EU’s strategic direction in key areas, such as reforms of the eurozone, the Greek debt crisis, the migrant challenge and relations with Russia. Mr. Tusk is expected to play a major role in the U.K.’s Brexit negotiations.
Threats
- Greek’s gross domestic product decreased by 1.2 percent in the October to December period on a quarterly basis, compared with a 0.4 percent contraction rate stated in a flash data released last month. The fourth quarter contraction was mainly due to as 2.1 percent decline in public consumption and weaker net exports. This negative growth data may complicate ongoing bailout talks.
- Next week on March 15, the Netherlands will hold national elections. The People’s Party for Freedom and Democracy, led by the current prime minister Mark Rutte, is leading in the polls. The anti-European Union, anti-immigration Party for Freedom, led by Geert Wilders, is a step below in the polls. If Mr. Wilders wins, he may take the Netherlands out of the EU. And, his victory may support presidential candidate Marine Le Pen in France, from the far right Front National party, who has vowed to pull France out of the euro, potentially bringing an end to the common currency project.
click to enlarge
- The Russian MICEX Index closed below its 200-day moving average for the first time in more than a year on Tuesday, a bearish sign to some investors. Investors pulled the most cash from Russia’s biggest exchange-traded fund in more than three years last week. The downtrend may continue with falling oil prices and optimism over sanctions removal fading.
© US Global Investors
www.usfunds.com
© U.S. Global Investors
Read more commentaries by U.S. Global Investors