Cycles Are Long Term

Doug Drabik discusses fixed income market conditions and offers insight for bond investors.

Recession and Expansion

Recessions are part of the economic cycle. No one looks forward to a recession because of the pain it can impose on investors or worse, job security. However, we can tend to overstress about its effect and minimize the potential impact of the long-term benefits of economic turnover. Recessions occur because something is out of whack. Interest rates are too high, a black swan event occurs (i.e. a pandemic), or inflation remains too high for too long causing consumers to stop spending. A recession can “reset” the market.

Higher interest rates often precede a recession. This is good for savers. If a recession occurs, the Fed typically eases its policy by lowering interest rates. This can help the mortgage market and create opportunities for other asset classes. It allows cheaper borrowing and expansion potential.

On average, recessions last less than a year. In comparison, expansions have lasted more than 5 years. One could argue that the Fed, by using more of its policy tools, has found ways to prolong expansionary periods without measurable recessionary consequences. The last 5 recessionary periods have averaged 0.9 years, the same average going back to 1945. On the other hand, the last 5 expansionary periods have averaged 7.6 years (and this one is still in progress), 46% longer than the average from 1945.

A recent black swan event, COVID-19, caused a mini-recession. It also changed consumer behavior. Businesses shut down and consumers brought savings to unprecedented levels. The government pumped money into the system, even directly into consumer pockets. As things turned, consumers spent a lot of money collapsing their record savings to below long-term averages. The current consumer spending behavior has depleted savings, used up government handouts, and continued to spend on borrowed money. Revolving credit is reaching record levels. Despite the euphoric media mantra proclaiming a robust economy and recession defeat, the strength of this growth might be built on a house of cards.