Jobs Report Masks a Still-Resilient Economy

The June employment report’s headline readout was softer than expected, but the details reinforce my view that the U.S. economy remains on a stable footing. Headline payroll growth disappointed, yet the previous two months—which had surprised to the upside—were revised lower, bringing hiring back toward a pace that is far more consistent with a mature expansion. Rather than signaling a sharp deterioration in labor demand, the report largely erased what had appeared to be an unsustainably strong burst of hiring earlier this spring.

The more surprising development was the sharp decline in labor force participation. Excluding the extraordinary distortions during the pandemic, participation has fallen to its lowest level in roughly half a century. According to the Household Survey, employment declined substantially, but the unemployment rate also fell because an unusually large number of workers exited the labor force altogether. Household Survey data are inherently volatile, so I hesitate to draw sweeping conclusions from a single month, but this bears close watching. The fact that most of the decline was among males ages 25–34 admits the possibility that this is a data aberration. The broader labor market, however, continues to look remarkably steady. Weekly jobless claims remain well-behaved, the JOLTS report still points to healthy labor demand, and there is little evidence elsewhere that the economy is slipping into recession.

The most important development for monetary policy continues to be energy prices. WTI crude has fallen to roughly $67 per barrel, commodity prices have largely surrendered their earlier gains, and shelter inflation remains subdued as rent growth flattens and home price appreciation slows dramatically. Gasoline prices have not declined as quickly because refining margins remain unusually elevated, reflecting refining capacity taken offline globally rather than rising crude prices. If those crack spreads normalize, they should provide another meaningful source of disinflation in the months ahead.

See more: Weekly Economic Snapshot: Resilience in the Labor Market